The official discord link if you wish to join the discord: https://discord.gg/j5RKwCvAFu

Support the wiki on our official Ko-Fi page or Patreon page!

Discussion Rules: Difference between revisions

From The Codex
GiverOfThePeace
GiverOfThePeace (talk | contribs) (→‎top: clean up and re-categorisation per CFD)
m
 
Line 18: Line 18:
|}
|}
==Introduction==
==Introduction==
The following page is regarding rules for discussions about certain verses, whether if the codex statistics section is wrong, general information is wrong, and more.
The following page is regarding rules for discussions about profiles, whether the codex statistics section is wrong or needs to be updated, general information is wrong or needs to be updated, powers and techniques are wrong or need to be updated, etcetera.


However, certain topics keep popping up repeatedly, generally made by new members, despite being discussed and resolved multiple times in the past. Due to the redundant nature, it is better to make a rule to ban discussion of certain conversations.
While there used to be rule bans for specific verses, this was eventually removed as it was deemed ultimately pointless and limited overall conversation. Especially with how various rules on the site change in frequent timeframes.
 
Do note the ban is purely based on the specific topic itself, a discussion based on something similar to the topic is allowed (I.E. Threads regarding upgrading Bob to tier 5 because he is stated to have the power to destroy the planet is banned because in context it was made by a crazy old person who has no legitimacy. If a new thread was made to upgrade Bob to tier 5 based on a reliable source saying it or him destroying the planet himself, that is fully allowed).


==General Rules==
==General Rules==
*It is advised that if you are planning to make a thread on a topic you check to see if other threads have been made regarding the topic.  
*It is advised that if you are planning to make a thread on a topic you check to see if other threads have been made regarding the topic.  
**It is also doubly advised to not be rude while on a thread, please be respectful.
**It is also doubly advised to not be rude while on a thread, please be respectful.
*When creating new discussion threads, it is required that our members add the relevant previously existing tags to them, for example the verse and most prominent characters that will be discussed during a content revision. If something goes wrong, and you need to add or change the tags of a certain thread, please ask [[The_Codex_Wiki_Staff_List|the staff]] for help.  
*When creating new discussion threads, it is required that our members add the relevant previously existing tags to them, for example, the verse and most prominent characters that will be discussed during a content revision. If something goes wrong, and you need to add or change the tags of a certain thread, please ask [[The_Codex_Wiki_Staff_List|the staff]] for help.  
*Only add tags that are directly relevant to the discussion threads. This includes the names of verses and characters for which revisions are being argued about.  
*Only add tags that are directly relevant to the discussion threads. This includes the names of verses and characters for which revisions are being argued.  
*When arguing for changing anything about a profile, do not assume that the commenters will have in-depth knowledge about the fictional franchise in question. Make sure to explain your suggestions in a structured manner that is easy to comprehend. This makes it far easier to evaluate threads. This also works the other way around however. Do not write overly long and complicated threads that no one will realistically read through, it is preferable to keep your arguments concise, comprehensible, and explanatory.  
*When arguing for changing anything about a profile, do not assume that the commenters will have in-depth knowledge about the fictional franchise in question. Make sure to explain your suggestions in a structured manner that is easy to comprehend. This makes it far easier to evaluate threads. This also works the other way around, however. Do not write overly long and complicated threads that no one will realistically read through, it is preferable to keep your arguments concise, comprehensible, and explanatory.  
*Content Revision Threads need to be supported by scans or any other direct proof that claimed events actually happened in the source material.
*Content Revision Threads need to be supported by scans or any other direct proof that claimed events happened in the source material.
*To get better input in a content revision thread, inspect the knowledgeable members list to get information about the people who know much about a franchise (you can find it on each franchises verse page).
*To get better input in a content revision thread, inspect the knowledgeable members list to get information about the people who know much about a franchise (you can find it on each franchise verse page).
*Generally try to avoid derailing content revision discussion threads from the original topic. Too many different subjects will cause a thread to never finish.
*Generally try to avoid derailing content revision discussion threads from the original topic. Too many different subjects will cause a thread to never finish.
*This rule is listed specifically towards admins, do not act like your opinion regarding a thread is the ultimate say towards it. A thread’s acceptance is based off if enough knowledgeable members agree to the changes provided, the staff’s job is only to moderate threads and make sure they stay on track, along with offer insight regarding how the site treats certain concepts.
*This rule is listed specifically towards admins, do not act like your opinion regarding a thread is the ultimate say towards it. A thread’s acceptance is based on if enough knowledgeable members agree to the changes provided, the staff’s job is only to moderate threads and make sure they stay on track, along with offering insight regarding how the site treats certain concepts.


[[Category:Important]]
[[Category:Important]]

Latest revision as of 23:11, 29 November 2024

Important Codex Wiki Articles
Important Pages The Codex Wiki - Site FAQ - General Help Page- Tiering System - Civilization Tiering System - Rules for Codex Profiles - Common Editing Mistakes - Disclaimer - How to Handle Calculations - Universe - Multiverse - Omniverse - Projectile and Objects Feats - Dimensional Tiering Explanation - Common Terminology - Discussion Rules - Reference for Common Feats - Rules for Acceptable Profiles - Rules for Fanon Profiles - Misleading Titles - Mistranslations - Outside Wiki Standards - Statements - Verse Cosmology Categorizations - Fictional Universes
Terminology Alignment - Status - Protection Level - Threat Level - Cardinality - Grade - Dimensionality - Attack Potency - Durability - Speed - Reactions - Lifting Strength - Striking Strength - Range - Intelligence - Knowledge - Powers and Techniques - State of Being - Physiology - Equipment - No Limits Fallacy - Omnipotence - Cinematic Time - Canon - Crossover - How to Handle Canon - Multipliers - Environmental Destruction - Bloodlust - Overtime Feats - Chain Reactions -Outside Help - Space - The Kardashev Scale - Infinity - Power Source - Light Speed - Requirements for Speed of Light/Faster Than Light Speeds
Standards Transcendence - Creation vs Destruction - Outlier - Ludonarrative Dissonance - Inconsistency - Plot-Induced Stupidity - Reality - Fiction Interaction - Powerscaling - Black Hole - Wormhole - Stabilization Feats - Merging Feats - Embodying Feats - Data World Standards - Dream World Standards - Standard Battle Assumptions - One-Shot - Speed Blitz - Penetration Damage - Blunt Force Damage - Death of the Author - Versus Threads - Information Pages - Light Dodging Feats - Lightning Standards - Void Standards
Formats Standard Format for Character Profiles - Standard Format for Factions - Standard Format for Cosmic Forces - Standard Format for Events - Standard Format for Verse Pages - Standard Format for Locations Profiles - Standard Format for Weapon Profiles - Standard Format for Powers and Abilities - Standard Format for Civilization Profiles - Standard Format for Category Names - Standard Templates For Tabbers
Fanon Fanon - Strongest Character Tier List - Weakest Character Tier List - Fanon/Strongest Smash Characters Tier List

Introduction

The following page is regarding rules for discussions about profiles, whether the codex statistics section is wrong or needs to be updated, general information is wrong or needs to be updated, powers and techniques are wrong or need to be updated, etcetera.

While there used to be rule bans for specific verses, this was eventually removed as it was deemed ultimately pointless and limited overall conversation. Especially with how various rules on the site change in frequent timeframes.

General Rules

  • It is advised that if you are planning to make a thread on a topic you check to see if other threads have been made regarding the topic.
    • It is also doubly advised to not be rude while on a thread, please be respectful.
  • When creating new discussion threads, it is required that our members add the relevant previously existing tags to them, for example, the verse and most prominent characters that will be discussed during a content revision. If something goes wrong, and you need to add or change the tags of a certain thread, please ask the staff for help.
  • Only add tags that are directly relevant to the discussion threads. This includes the names of verses and characters for which revisions are being argued.
  • When arguing for changing anything about a profile, do not assume that the commenters will have in-depth knowledge about the fictional franchise in question. Make sure to explain your suggestions in a structured manner that is easy to comprehend. This makes it far easier to evaluate threads. This also works the other way around, however. Do not write overly long and complicated threads that no one will realistically read through, it is preferable to keep your arguments concise, comprehensible, and explanatory.
  • Content Revision Threads need to be supported by scans or any other direct proof that claimed events happened in the source material.
  • To get better input in a content revision thread, inspect the knowledgeable members list to get information about the people who know much about a franchise (you can find it on each franchise verse page).
  • Generally try to avoid derailing content revision discussion threads from the original topic. Too many different subjects will cause a thread to never finish.
  • This rule is listed specifically towards admins, do not act like your opinion regarding a thread is the ultimate say towards it. A thread’s acceptance is based on if enough knowledgeable members agree to the changes provided, the staff’s job is only to moderate threads and make sure they stay on track, along with offering insight regarding how the site treats certain concepts.